Comments: Time for a revival

Keep chattering... we're listening.

Haven't played Patrician... but I've become wary of Michael Schacht games recently, as they are starting to feel same-y.

Posted by Mark Jackson at September 26, 2007 1:47 PM

Susan, I just played Patrician for the first time last week. We played with five and it laid a huge egg. The early moves didn't seem to matter, the end came very quickly, and the control seemed minimal. Plus, it sure felt like the first player was at a considerable disadvantage. I'm glad to hear it plays better with three, but it might be really tough getting it back on the table.

Posted by Larry Levy at September 26, 2007 9:21 PM

I have a pink PC as well! Mine is a Sony Vaio - and yes, I waited until they had re-stocked the pink ones. Of course, with 2 daughters, it may not have been the best choice - there are threats of competition for Mummy's Work PC.

Posted by Melissa at September 27, 2007 12:32 AM

Mark: You have good reason to be wary. Patrician is same-y. I played Web of Power on the same day and was struck by the fact both use the mechanism of playing a card out of a very limited hand to place a piece in the corresponding region to attempt to get a majority there. Web of Power is far cleverer and has more going on, but Patrician (with 3) isn't bad and it is easier to teach and plays even more quickly if those are qualities you are looking for. It's a game that I'd be happy to play every now and then, but I wouldn't buy it.

Larry: I would have to really be sweet talked into playing this game again with five or even four. My first game was with five also. I wouldn't blame anyone if it never hit the table again after that. A few players at the table thought it was at least okay. Since I have a review copy, I felt obligated to give it another go and I had other unsuspecting victims. So if you get another chance, try it with three players. If not, well, there are plenty of better light, filler games out there so no real loss.

Melissa: I even have a matching pink mouse and a pink and white carrying case for my laptop. I've never been much of a "pink" girlie girl, but I had to stake my claim somehow!

Posted by Susan at September 27, 2007 12:03 PM
Post a comment